Reach Us +1 218 451 2974
All submissions of the EM system will be redirected to Online Manuscript Submission System. Authors are requested to submit articles directly to Online Manuscript Submission System of respective journal.

A Case Report of Death Claimed Due To Oral Polio Vaccine (OPV)

Raghvendra Singh1*, Raja Rupani1, Anoop Kumar Verma1, Mousami Singh1, Shiuli Rathore1, Heena Singh2 and Sangeeta Kumari1

1Department Of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology, King George's Medical University, Lucknow, U.P, India

2Department Of Anatomy, King George’s Medical University, Lucknow, U.P, India

Corresponding Author:
Raghvendra singh
Department of Forensic Medicine & Toxicology
King George's Medical University, Lucknow, U.P, India
Tel: 9532906700
E-mail: [email protected]

Citation: Singh R, Rupani R, Verma AK. et al. A Case Report of Death Claimed Due To Oral Polio Vaccine (OPV). J Med toxicol clin forensic med. 2015, 1:1.

 

Abstract

To eradicate polio, India introduced special drive of OPV immunisation. We are describing a case of death claimed due to OPV, brought to mortuary at King George’s Medical University, Lucknow, North India. Some religious communities oppose OPV drive continuously because, to them OPV seems to be an objectionable material and can lead to ill effects to their children. Hence, such type of cases need a careful examination as they can create panic in the society and media and jeopardise all attempts to eliminate polio. In this case, besides considering OPV, we also came across many factors like, subgaleal haemorrhage and bottle feeding. These factors could also be a cause of infant death, but after careful Post mortem examination, we found that the main culprit was feeding bottle.

Keywords

Oral polio vaccine; Newborn; Subgaleal haemorrhage; Bottle feeding

Introduction

India has been declared polio free by WHO [1]. Polio Eradication efforts will continue till polio is globally eradicated. Some religious communities keep on objecting over polio vaccination drive. They think that polio vaccination may cause harm to their children. So it is very important to make them clear that nothing is harmful in polio drops and it is the responsibility of the leaders, of these religious communities, to remove misconceptions about use of vaccines to protect children of their community from this crippling disease. We describe a case of death claimed to be due to OPV, brought to mortuary at King George’s Medical University, Lucknow, North India for expert autopsy. These cases can further consolidate the rumour that OPV contains objectionable material, which can lead to death of their children; otherwise all attempts to completely eliminate the polio from the world will go in vain.

Case Report

A case of death was reported due to OPV in a full term new-born male child, of one day old, weighing 1.8 kg, who was delivered by normal vaginal delivery at a hospital. At home, mother found her one day old infant dead in his crib, in supine position. One hour prior to incident, infant had received OPV. Hence she thought that the incidence occurred due to adverse effect of OPV. Death scene investigation and parental assessment did not yield any other specific cause of death. Autopsy was conducted & we came across the following findings:

External findings

On examination there was no external finding, except bluish discolouration of nails.

Internal findings

Visceras were congested. There was subgaleal collection of clotted blood at occipital area over the skull (area 5 cm * 4 cm and volume 15-20 ml) (Figure 1). Stomach was filled with semi digested curdy milk.

toxicology-clotted-blood

Figure 1: Subgalleal clotted blood.

On opening trachea and bronchi we found a white coloured fluid (approx. 4-5 ml) at tracheo-bronchial region (Figure 2). This fluid was collected and sent for biochemical examination.

toxicology-trachea

Figure 2: Fluid (milk) present in trachea.

Cause of death was still not clear and hanged on three points-

First was any adverse reaction due to OPV

Second was the blood loss due to subgaleal haemorrhage, as a consequence of instrumentation during vaginal delivery.

And thirdly, the fluid present at tracheo-bronchial region, similar to be milk which could be mucous also.

According to WHO, OPV is a heat sensitive vaccine. WHO uses a vaccine vial monitor to assess cold chain and prevent any expired vaccine to be introduced in immunisation. On examination of Vaccine vial monitor of suspected polio vaccine, Inner Square was found to be lighter than outer circle proving maintenance of cold chain and also expiry date was not yet passed (Figure 3) [2]. Subgaleal haemorrhage is most serious complication of instrumental delivery, although rare, is associated with significant morbidity and mortality [3]. As it is not limited by suture line, the new-born can therefore lose up to 80% of their blood volume within the subaponeurotic space resulting in hypovolemic shock, acute anaemia, coagulopathy and death [4] but volume of subgaleal bleed was much less in this case. Thirdly we focussed on biochemical examination of fluid found at the tracheo-bronchial region. Initially, biuret test was done for screening of casein and result was found to be positive. To confirm this, we tested presence of casein in given fluid using ELISA SYSTEMS Casein Residue assay. This assay confirmed the presence of milk in tracheo-bronchial region. Since gastro-oesophageal reflux is more common among new borns [5], so our next step was to detect the origin of this milk, that whether this milk reached at tracheo-bronchial junction as a result of gastro-oesophageal reflux or directly during faulty feeding. To differentiate it, we collected two samples - sample no.1 from stomach milk and sample no.2 from tracheo-bronchial milk and pH test was performed on those samples. Result was surprising as pH of both samples were different. pH of sample no.1 was 4.02 while pH of sample no.2 was 7.23. Difference in pH and consistency indicated that the milk aspiration was caused directly by faulty feeding and not because of gastro-oesophageal reflux, as it was assumed earlier.

toxicology-Polio-vaccine

Figure 3: Vial of suspected Polio vaccine.

Discussion

According to WHO, OPV is contraindicated in families where children or their close contacts are immune compromised. The only grave complication of OPV is Vaccine Associated Paralytic Poliomyelitis [6]. Death may occur as a result of respiratory failure (5 to 10%) in vaccine derived polio virus but never as early as within 1-2 hour. Subgaleal haemorrhage although rare, is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Uchil et al. in 2003 reported incidence of subgaleal haemorrhage in 0.4/1000 cases of spontaneous vaginal births and 5.9/1000 cases of vacuum births [4]. On careful examination of medical records at the time of delivery, we found that proper surveillance methods were adapted from the RANZCOG Recommendations [7] and there was no reported abnormality regarding - heart rate, respiratory rate, colour (pallor) and activity. So subgaleal haemorrhage can easily be excluded to be the cause of death. On proper history of feeding practices, we came to know that caregiver of infant, along with breast feeding also used feeding bottle, which has its own adverse effects. Improper breast feeding may cause infant death in some cases, especially in new-borns with Low Birth Weight, if suck reflux is poorly developed [8]. But death by aspiration of milk in a term new-born with proper breast feeding is a rare event. It has been described earlier, that improper position during feeding of milk with bottle may lead to infant death if not supervised by caretaker [9]. On examining the bottle, we found one more significant point that, the rate of dispense of milk through that feeding bottle was unlikely very high. The very high rates of delivery of milk through this bottle definitely lead to pooling of milk into naso-oral cavity and from there it got aspirated into lungs and lead to death of this new-born.

Conclusion

Post mortem examination of these cases should be done carefully, on failing of which such type of cases can consolidate the rumours that OPV contains objectionable material, against some community, and all effect to counter polio will go into vain. Health workers should be specially trained to curb these types of rumours. Particularly, in this case scenario, they should inform people to be aware from such rumours and discourage use of feeding bottles and thus prevent new-born morbidity and mortality in developing country.

Declaration of Funding Information and Conflict of Interest, If Any

There is no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or profit and non-profit sector. The author declares that there is no conflict of interest.

References

Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language

Viewing options

Post your comment

Share This Article

Flyer image
journal indexing image
 

Post your comment

captcha   Reload  Can't read the image? click here to refresh